The two columns I found similar in Chris Rose's 1 Dead in Attic were "Despair" and "Good-Bye." At first the only to things I found in common with these two articles were that they both affected me deeply to the point where I was wiping tears from my eyes as I read them. Then there is the very obvious fact that they both deal with the horror of the aftermath in a way that tugs at the heartstrings and makes you realize just how devastating the losses of Katrina were. In both passages the primary focus is the impact the hurricane had on families.
Both passages deal with death and chronicle death in a raw, emotional format.
In the first one entitled "Despair" Rose chronicles the tragedy of a couple that were happily engaged in New Orleans before the storm. The woman refuses to leave New Orleans because "she is a New Orleans girl and New Orleans girls never live anywehre else and even if they do, they always come back" (61). After the storm they struggle at their attempt to live happily among the ruins of the city. They decide it is too much for them, and the man kills himself. This story is especially troubling because unlike the majority of the tragedies this one is not a case of an accidental death due to the storm but instead tries to depict how hard it was to live after the storm. It is as if surviving Katrina itself wasn't enough but living with the memory and in the wake of Katrina was just as challenging. In other words it shows how much it takes to survive a tragedy not only physically but psychologically as well.
The passage entitled "Good-Bye" delves into some similar themes, specifically on how the hurricane impacted familial relationships. This passage does a particularly good job of elaborating on how difficult it was to explain what had happened to his children. They, being so young can only relate it to how it affects them directly, what happened to their stuff their friends etc. While trying to explain what is happening Rose struggles ot phrase the tragedy in a way that will make them understand but won't truamatize them. When he explains that some of their friends are gone. While he doesn't explain the fates of his childrens friends directly it is heavily implied that they died in the hurricane.
While there are a great deal of differenes within the situations in the two passages the most prevalent similarity is that they explore the psychological damages during the aftermath. They also explore the theme of love and how sometimes it isn't enough. In the case of the first passage the love between the couple was not enough to help them through Katrina, not because they did not love each other but because there was only so love can do. In the second passage it seems that Rose's love for his kids is helping him cope with the tragedy. By using protecting his kids it seems he is almost helping to protect his own psyche.
The one recurring theme throughout the book is the constantly looming question how do we move past this? How do we get over it? The general answer seems to be; we don't, we just move forward. And even though the outcomes within the two passages are drastically different, one ends in tragedy and one ends with hope, they both deal with progression in the aftermath.
No comments:
Post a Comment